Archive for September 7th, 2010

Fairfield Weekly: ‘Linda McMahon Did Or Should Have Understood WWE’s Lethal Culture’

“The Business of Death”

by Nick Keppler

Fairfield Weekly

http://www.fairfieldweekly.com/news/featured-news/the-business-of-death

Linda McMahon’s WWE Invoked ‘Death Clause’ in Owen Hart Lawsuit — Then Made a Virtue Out of the Necessity of Its $18 Million Settlement

The headline over today’s piece by Ed Stannard in the New Haven Register is “Yale law prof disputes McMahon camp stance on ‘death clause’.” See http://www.nhregister.com/articles/2010/09/07/news/doc4c86be62d62e9475981222.txt.

The story notes that in a media conference call organized by the Connecticut Democratic Party, the professor, Robert Solomon, noted that, contrary to its representation to the Manchester Journal Inquirer, World Wrestling Entertainment, on at least one occasion, had  invoked the clause in its talent contracts releasing claims against the company even in the event of death caused by the promoter’s negligence. That occasion was WWE’s defense of the lawsuit by the estate of Owen Hart, who was killed during a stunt entrance at a show in Kansas City in 1999 when his defective harness broke. Hart’s widow and the company ultimately settled the dispute for $18 million.

The audio of the Democratic Party’s teleconference featuring Professor Solomon can be heard at http://www.ctnewsjunkie.com/ctnj.php/archives/entry/democrats_yale_law_professor_debunk_mcmahon_campaigns_death_clause_claim/. In the course of his remarks, Solomon also makes the broader point that WWE’s claim that its performers are independent contractors is both specious and immoral.

For those of you who are skeptical of experts, Ivy League professors, or media events staged by political parties, I suggest that you turn to my posts of September 3 in reaction to Don Michak’s article in the Journal Inquirer:

* “Linda McMahon’s Defense of WWE Contract Death Clauses Is, ‘We Don’t Really Mean It’,” https://wrestlingbabylon.wordpress.com/2010/09/03/linda-mcmahons-defense-of-wwe-contract-death-clauses-is-we-dont-really-mean-it/.

* “Linda McMahon & WWE Full of Bull in Response to Connecticut Newspaper ‘Death Clause’ Story,” https://wrestlingbabylon.wordpress.com/2010/09/03/linda-mcmahon-wwe-full-of-bull-in-response-to-connecticut-newspaper-death-clause-story/.

Professor Solomon is right in observing that WWE’s multimillion-dollar settlement with the Hart estate doesn’t disprove that it initially invoked the death clause as a defense in that action. On the contrary, as Solomon says, it makes the company’s position on the death clause worse.

As someone who is not licensed to practice law and has never argued a case at a level higher than small claims court, I can help everyone out here by reducing the position of Linda McMahon’s corporate sugar daddy to its language-twisting essence. This Senate candidate and her underwriter are very good at making a virtue out of necessity — much better than they are at taking care of the health and welfare of their employees.

Irv Muchnick

Start of NFL Season Highlights Significance of Fate of Linda McMahon’s Senate Campaign

In an insightful column headlined “The last season of the NFL as you know it,” Scott Ostler, a writer for the San Francisco Chronicle, talks about how the push by pro football owners for expansion from a 16- to an 18-game season, along with the threat of a players’ strike or owners’ lockout next season, is reshaping the landscape of America’s most popular and profitable sport. But Ostler has more than just labor relations in mind:

We’ll start at the head. Football was more fun for fans (and owners) in the days when a player “got his bell rung.” It validated our belief that football is dangerous and edgy, but in a cartoonish way; and it gave players a chance to prove their toughness when they staggered back to action with their helmet on backward.

Now we know more about such brain-damaging blows…. Each study seems to top the previous one on the fright scale…. The down-the-line consequences are frightening. There is evidence that repeated blows can lead to a condition with symptoms almost identical to Lou Gehrig’s disease….

(See http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/c/a/2010/09/06/SPDF1F95P1.DTL.)

Last week Ostler’s Chronicle colleague Gwen Knapp wrote a column for CBSSports.com, linked here at the time, which argued that the Senate campaign in Connecticut of Linda McMahon, who made her campaign-financing fortune from World Wrestling Entertainment, would be a referendum of sorts on steroids in sports.

Like Knapp, I’m here to tell you that the way the McMahon family has managed pro wrestling has ramifications far beyond the boundaries of that largely under-the-radar world. Unlike Knapp, I’m now adding that steroids, per se, are only part of the story. Today we have a sports culture and a popular culture that, consciously or not, glorify industrialized death as an appropriate element of mass entertainment. Just as Linda McMahon’s WWE is at the unexamined cutting edge of steroid abuse, so is it at the lightly regarded end of the continuum on the issue of the consequences of serial and untreated concussions in contact sports.

My point is that, even if you don’t give a damn about wrestling, you ought to be giving a damn.

Irv Muchnick

Muchnick Flashback — EXCLUSIVE: Linda McMahon’s WWE Medical Director Met With Chris Benoit Brain Experts in 2008

The following item was originally posted here on December 14, 2009. The 2010 National Football League season starts this week.

In a December 9 article at ESPN.com about the brain damage of yet another dead pro wrestler, Andrew “Test” Martin (http://sports.espn.go.com/espn/otl/news/story?id=4724912), World Wrestling Entertainment – the company of Connecticut U.S. Senate candidate Linda McMahon – stated  in part:

“WWE is unaware of the veracity of any of these tests, be it for Chris Benoit or Andrew Martin…. WWE has been asking to see the research and test results in the case of Mr. Benoit for years and has not been supplied with them.”

The second sentence is a grossly, and characteristically, misleading statement by the McMahon death mill. The following background reveals that “lie” may not be too strong a word.

Here’s the full chronology.

In June 2007 WWE star Chris Benoit murdered his wife and their son, and killed himself. Chris Nowinski, a former pro wrestler who had been forced to retire because of the cumulative effects of in-ring concussions, had started a research and advocacy group, and Nowinski prevailed upon Chris Benoit’s father, Mike Benoit, to donate his son’s brain for studies by Dr. Bennet Omalu, a pioneering researcher of what is being called Chronic Traumatic Encephalopathy. Later in the year Nowinski and Mike Benoit widely publicized Omalu’s research.

In March 2008 WWE began baseline neurological testing for its performers, using an emerging system of sports-medicine protocols called ImPACT. WWE itself did not announce this change. However, in an April 11, 2008, news release, Sports Legacy Institute’s Nowinski, citing “anonymous wrestlers,” reported: “WWE management has instituted a concussion management program. At a mandatory meeting for all performers in early March WWE performers took a computerized neuropsychological testing protocol, which evaluates such things as memory, cognitive skills, and reaction time. They will be re-tested aggressively every 6 months to look for long term health issues, as well as re-tested after suspected concussions to help determine when it is safe to return to in-ring action.”

According to Dave Meltzer, publisher of the authoritative Wrestling Observer Newsletter, March 2008 corresponds with when Dr. Joseph Maroon was hired to coordinate WWE’s ImPACT program and supervise the work of two doctors who henceforth traveled to all WWE shows.

On October 1, 2008, Dr. Maroon visited the Brain Injury Research Institute in Morgantown, West Virginia. The institute is co-directed by Dr. Julian Bailes, chair of the neurosurgery department at West Virginia University, and Dr. Omalu, a medical professor and coroner now based in California. Also present at the meeting were the brain institute’s general counsel, Bob Fitzsimmons, and Peter Davies, a professor of pathology and neuroscience at Yeshiva University’s Albert Einstein College of Medicine in New York.

On the phone with me this morning, Omalu was hopping mad about the WWE statement to ESPN. “Dr. Maroon was there with us and he was shown all our research information, slides, and specimens – on Chris Benoit and all the athletes’ brains we studied,” Omalu said.

The only possible confusion about any of this would be painfully hairsplitting. But that’s WWE’s m.o.

Maroon also has long been a team physician for the National Football League’s Pittsburgh Steelers, and a familiar NFL consultant throughout the public debate in recent years – culminating in hearings earlier this year before the House Judiciary Committee – over football concussions. An impossibly tortured rationalization could be offered to the effect that when Maroon was in West Virginia, he was representing the NFL but not also WWE.

The WWE corporate website prominently calls Maroon the company “medical director.” Maroon’s own website and bio at the University of Pittsburgh Medical Center say he became WWE medical director “in 2008,” though not the month. Again, March 2008 was when the company hired Maroon with a brain-injury portfolio, whether or not the title at the time was “medical director.”

Omalu pointed out that there is a lot more to how this story relates to the slow and grudging acceptance of his research by the NFL as well as by WWE. The October 2008 meeting was his third with Maroon dating back to 2006. Like WWE, the NFL started with a bureaucratic Alphonse-and-Gaston act of pretending to ignore Omalu or discredit his research. More on all that another day.

For now, the story is that WWE’s medical director was given full access to Chris Benoit brain studies, in person, 14 months before WWE told ESPN that the company “has been asking to see the research and tests results in the case of Mr. Benoit for years and has not been supplied with them.”

This morning I emailed and left a voicemail message for Dr. Maroon in Pittsburgh. If he, or WWE or the McMahon family’s litigious attack dog Jerry McDevitt, has anything to add to our understanding of this scenario, I will post it immediately.

The next question is whether the Connecticut media will make this latest tale of WWE death and deception stick to Linda McMahon, who was merely CEO of the company and is the wife of chairman Vince McMahon.

Or will this be treated as just another political fun-and-games story from the wacky world of wrestling?

Irv Muchnick


Irv’s Tweets

September 2010
M T W T F S S
« Aug   Oct »
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
27282930