Archive for June, 2009

Gina Carano Doesn’t Exist in the East Bay Express

Last week the East Bay Express, based in Berkeley, California, ran a cover story on female mixed martial arts in the area. You can read it at

Focusing on a particular local trainer, it was an OK-enough article, except for this glaring statement:

“But will there be a place for these fighters to compete? Since 2007, two of the leading companies holding women’s MMA fights have folded. Fatal Femmes Fighting has spent the year reorganizing, bowed by the economic realities where there aren’t many people willing to pay $25 to see an all-women’s card. Sherdog’s Hunt thinks that women’s mixed martial arts is at the same point as the men’s sport was seven or eight years ago. ‘There’s a handful of really good athletes that know the sport, but there’s not enough opportunities,’ Hunt says.”

What the Express doesn’t add is that on August 15, at the HP Pavilion in San Jose — 50 miles from Berkeley — Strikeforce is presenting the first-ever televised MMA card (on Showtime) headlined by a women’s match: Gina “Conviction” Carano vs. Cristiane “Cyborg” Santos.

A story on women’s MMA that doesn’t even mention Gina Carano, a crossover glamour girl who also boasts world-class legitimacy in both Muay Thai, a specialized strike sport, and MMA is a little like breaking down women in auto racing without a reference to Danica Patrick.

I sent a nice note to the Express, which apparently has decided not to tap out to the obvious omission.

The Express snidely covered the launch of my first book, Wrestling Babylon. If the paper responds similarly to the publication of my upcoming Chris & Nancy: The True Story of the Benoit Murder-Suicide and Pro Wrestling’s Cocktail of Death, y’all will know why.

Irv Muchnick

Muchnick / Bret Hart CNN Exchange Popular at YouTube

The clip from the June 29, 2007, edition of CNN’s Nancy Grace, with an exchange between author Irvin Muchnick and retired wrestler Bret Hart about the role of steroids in the Chris Benoit double murder/suicide, is the first clip on the new WrestlingBabylon channel at YouTube to surpass 1,000 views.

The  channel is at

“Irvin Muchnick Challenges Wrestling Legend Bret Hart” is at

Historical Footnote on Wrestler Brian Blair

Brian Blair, a retired wrestler who most recently was an elected commissioner of Hillsborough County, Florida, has been arrested and jailed in Tampa on charges that he punched his two sons and put the older son, who is 17, in a chokehold. See

At the 1991 federal trial of Dr. George Zahorian — the then World Wrestling Federation ringside physician in Pennsylvania — Blair testified that he received shipments of steroids from Zahorian.

Irv Muchnick

Donald Trump, WWE, And the SEC

In a Friday piece headlined “GE and WWE in Violation of Securities Law?”,, Kathryn Glass of Fox News wondered about the storyline “sale” of World Wrestling Entertainment’s Raw brand to Donald Trump.

Trump’s involvement is a ratings stunt for the USA cable network show Monday Night Raw. (USA is owned by GE. Raw is one of WWE’s three wrestling troupes; the others are Smackdown and ECW.)

The Fox article noted that a USA press release, which did not identify the Trump purchase of Raw as a TV shtick, was distributed via PR Newswire, a business and corporate-relations service. In response, shares of WWE, which is listed at the New York Stock Exchange, fell Tuesday more than seven percent, to $12.18 per share, after opening at $13.13, arguably because some naive investors fell for the ruse.

The Securities and Exchange Commission prohibits the dissemination by publicly traded companies of materially false statements. This subject came up with respect to WWE in another incident two years ago, which is covered in my forthcoming book on the Chris Benoit double murder/suicide. (Tomorrow is the anniversary of the strangulation of Nancy Benoit, the first of the three deaths.) On the day the Benoit family’s bodies were found, WWE was scheduled to air a special edition of Monday Night Raw with a memorial to WWE chairman (and TV bad guy) Vince McMahon, who had been “murdered” by a car bomb. It was one thing for WWE to hype a storyline on its entertainment website, but in this case the corporation also put out a press release through its investors website, a move that Darren Rovell of CNBC questioned.

Yesterday, on the Wrestling Observer Newsletter website, Bryan Alvarez, the publisher of Observer affiliate Figure Four Weekly, wrote of the Fox story about Trump: “Sometimes it’s a bit annoying when wrestling falls under the radar because ‘it’s just wrestling.’ but with something like this, there aren’t more important things to do in the financial world?”

Unfortunately, my friend Bryan gets the tone here precisely wrong. The tipoff is his solipsistic phrase “a bit annoying.”

Yes, the Madoff scandal is more important than a goofball press release. But Alvarez doesn’t cover the financial world. He covers pro wrestling. How wrestling gets regulated, or not, affects a lot of things for wrestling fans and for talent. For example, in recent years the latter have experienced an avoidable and obscenely high volume of early deaths.

I’m not sure exactly what wrestling journalists who want to be taken seriously accomplish when they treat real-world stories so flippantly. For this reader, the only thing they accomplish is a careless signal that they — like wrestling promoters — enjoy having it both ways.

Irv Muchnick

‘No WWE in Benoit Wrongful-Death Suit’ (full text from SLAM! Wrestling)

[originally published on June 12 at SLAM! Wrestling under the headline “No WWE in Benoit wrongful-death suit — only Dr. Astin and “Distributors X, Y, Z,”

By Irvin Muchnick

On Wednesday the family of Chris Benoit’s wife Nancy brought down the civil litigation hammer, filing a wrongful-death lawsuit in U.S. District Court in Newnan, Georgia, over the June 2007 murders by Chris of Nancy and their son Daniel (which were followed by Chris’s suicide).

But as was speculated in this space on Tuesday [Second anniversary of Benoit tragedy slams shut another door on reform], the target of the suit by Nancy’s parents, Maureen and Paul Toffoloni, is not World Wrestling Entertainment. Rather, it is Dr. Phil Astin, Chris’s personal physician, who already has been sentenced to 10 years in federal prison after the Drug Enforcement Administration busted him for wildly overprescribing drugs to his patients.

(Prosecutors told the sentencing judge that two Astin patients other than the Benoits had died as a result of the doctor’s prescription abuses. One of these patients was Mike “Johnny Grunge” Dunham. The other was believed to be Sherry “Sensational Sherri” Russell.)

The Toffolonis’ complaint introduces a new element to the Benoit mystery in its inclusion of three co-defendants, who are referred to as “Distributor X,” “Distributor Y,” and “Distributor Z.” According to the complainants, the identities of these defendants are currently unknown to them, except to the extent that they are “for profit entities doing business in the State of Georgia” and are “manufacturers, distributors, wholesalers and/or retail sellers of certain anabolic androgenic steroids, narcotic drugs, and/or controlled substances.”

Dr. Astin himself is accused of being a proximate cause of the Benoits’ deaths because of his negligent medical care and treatment of Chris, which began in June 2000. During that period, the complaint says, Astin’s actions put Chris “under the influence of CNS [central nervous system] depressants, opioids and anabolic androgenic steroids,” which impaired him mentally and triggered his homicidal-suicidal rampage across a weekend at the family’s home outside Fayetteville.

Both individually and on behalf of Nancy and Daniel’s estates, Maureen and Paul Toffoloni seek a jury trial and recovery of damages for “the full value of the lives of each decedent”; “final expenses, including funeral expenses”; and “compensatory damages for the fear, shock, mental and emotional trauma, and extreme pain and suffering endured by Nancy E. Benoit and Daniel Benoit prior to their deaths.” The plaintiffs also ask for punitive damages flowing from the defendants’ “willful misconduct, malice, fraud, wantonness, oppression, [with an assumption of] conscious indifference to consequences.”

At least three motivations could underly the decision by the family and their attorney, Richard P. Decker, to structure a three-fourths-unnamed defense group. One may be the struggle to locate a culpable party with deep pockets. The only hope of recovering monetary damages from the broken and imprisoned Astin himself would almost certainly be through his malpractice insurer. The Toffolonis may be betting on discovery and new evidence generated by a trial to identify the Atlanta area non-licensed pharmaceutical sources of what we already know, through the Fayette County sheriff’s criminal investigation and through the DEA’s case against Astin, was Chris Benoit’s astounding personal inventory of drugs.

The second motivation may be the need, for civil wrongful-death purposes, to establish something that was missing from the Astin prosecution: counts involving steroids and human growth hormone (not just painkillers and antidepressants). The network for those substances reaches beyond the doctor himself to the netherworld of online and other black-market dealers, and might involve recreational drugs as well.

A third motivation may well be grounded in pure principle — in a simple determination by the Toffolonis to use the civil legal system to expose as much as they possibly can about the circumstances that led to the horrific loss of their loved ones.

“We are not money-hungry people and that is not what this is about for us,” Nancy’s sister, Sandra Toffoloni, told me last year. “We have lost everything. Everything. I firmly believe there is responsibility to be taken, not just by Christopher.”

A facsimile of Wednesday’s 15-page complaint can be viewed through my website at

Irvin Muchnick’s Chris & Nancy: The True Story of the Benoit Murder-Suicide and Pro Wrestling’s Cocktail of Death will be published this fall by ECW Press. Pre-order and other info is at

WrestlingBabylon / Chris & Nancy YouTube Channel Launched

A channel collecting the media appearances of Irvin Muchnick, author of WRESTLING BABYLON: Piledriving Tales of Drugs, Sex, Death, and Scandal (2007) and the forthcoming CHRIS & NANCY: The True Story of the Benoit Murder-Suicide and Pro Wrestling’s Cocktail of Death, is now live at YouTube.

The URL is

Here is a list of the current content:

* Irv challenges wrestling legend Bret Hart about steroids on CNN’s “Nancy Grace,” June 29, 2007:

* Irv dukes it out with Bill O’Reilly on Fox News’ “O’Reilly Factor,” June 27, 2007:

* Irv is among those interviewed for a report on the Chris Benoit case and death in pro wrestling on France’s “L’Effet Papillon,” Canal + network, May 25, 2008:

* Irv is among those interviewed for an hour-long documentary on Chris Benoit and death in pro wrestling on the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation’s “the fifth estate,” February 6, 2008, in seven parts on YouTube beginning:

* Irv is the featured guest on “The Josh Kornbluth Show,” KQED-TV, San Francisco, February 26, 2007, in four parts on YouTube beginning:

* Irv is interviewed live by Gary Radnich, KRON4 News, San Francisco, March 22, 2007:

* Irv is interviewed about the Benoit case on WOC AM, Davenport, Iowa, April 8, 2008:

* In footage acquired by Irv after a fight before the Connecticut Freedom of Information Commission, Stamford police interrogate the “Benoit Wikipedia hacker,” June 29, 2007, in three parts on YouTube beginning:

‘Steroid Cloud Hovers Over Baseball’s Feel-Good Stories’ (full text from Beyond Chron)

[originally published at Beyond Chron on June 15,]

By Irvin Muchnick

Anyone who cares about good government must scour the Washington coverage critically. Similarly, if the public-health implications of sports’ steroid scandals matter, you need to read the sports pages with equal skepticism. The feel-good comeback narratives of two baseball players – Rick Ankiel of the St. Louis Cardinals and Josh Hamilton of the Texas Rangers – illustrate the latter point.

Both Ankiel and Hamilton were on the list of athletes and entertainers, compiled in 2007 by the Albany, New York, district attorney’s office, who received shipments of steroids or human growth hormone from the gray-market Internet dealer Signature Pharmacy.

I don’t mind Ankiel and Hamilton being forgiven for their mistakes – any more than I begrudge Miguel Tejada, a one-time hero in my household, for his fine current (and, apparently, performance-enhancing-drug-free) season.

The steroid story should not just be about naming names. Still, only an apologist could argue that the game of gotcha has no real-world value. Specific examples reveal the range of subtle motivations and manipulations of drug cheats. Again, the key word is “drug,” not “cheats.” Hundreds of pro wrestlers have died young over the last generation. In the coming decades, dozens of our “legitimate” athletes will follow them in the record book of life.

Rick Ankiel was a phenomenal rookie pitcher for the St. Louis Cardinals in 2000, whose career went suddenly south in an incurable bout of wildness. In a makeover unprecedented in modern baseball, Ankiel reinvented himself as a slugging outfielder and returned to the major leagues two years ago. Then came the Signature Pharmacy revelation, but it blew over.

“Crash adds chapter to Ankiel’s amazing story,” read the headline in the St. Louis Post-Dispatch on May 5 of this year. Ankiel had just injured himself running face-first into the center field wall at Busch Stadium on a great catch. He got hurt “playing the way he always has approached any of his baseball jobs: full speed ahead,” wrote baseball columnist Rick Hummel, who has been inducted into the writers’ wing of the Baseball Hall of Fame and is nicknamed “Commish” (for “commissioner”).

Cardinals manager Tony La Russa called Ankiel “a guy who’s had more than his share of adversity, but he’s shown a lot of courage and strength.” La Russa’s chief lieutenant, Dave Duncan, added, “You have a certain respect for all the things he’s gone through and how he’s dealt with it.”

Not a word from the Commish about Signature. Though the trauma injury of crashing into a wall didn’t have anything to do with steroids, a full account of Ankiel’s “amazing” biography surely did. But as Mark McGwire said to Congress, who wants to talk about the past?

Josh Hamilton was a seemingly can’t-miss prospect who seemingly missed, due to drug addiction. Eight times he went into rehab to shake a cluster of vices, including crack cocaine. Last year he finally emerged as a star with the Texas Rangers, driving in an otherworldly 95 runs in the first half before tailing off, and putting on a show for the ages at the homer-hitting contest before the All-Star Game.

Like Ankiel, Hamilton has a hard time staying off the disabled list. (Ankiel tore a muscle in his side, hampering his swing, just as he was returning to the lineup following his outfield collision.) Now Hamilton is shelved by a torn abdominal muscle, which is said to be a result of running into a wall. Maybe, though running into walls usually causes bruises, not the torn abs, pectorals, and triceps that are relatively recent line items in the sports medicine literature, and are ascribed by experts to steroid abuse, which causes overdeveloped muscles to overload the tendons holding them together.

“Hamilton’s past might still haunt him,” read the headline in Yahoo Sports on June 9. This story was written by Gordon Edes, who last year left the sinking ship of The Boston Globe to become Yahoo’s baseball columnist.

Was “Hamilton’s past” a reference to his steroid/HGH use? Naw. It was the cocaine.

Jose Vasquez, the Rangers’ strength and conditioning coach, who called Hamilton’s strength “off the charts,” told Edes, “His challenge is his health. We just don’t know how his body will bounce back from all those years of drug use. It’s a mystery to all of us.”

Edes wrote that the team was worried about Hamilton’s recovery from surgery: “Last season, Hamilton had a stomach ailment that sent him to the hospital; he wound up on the disabled list. ‘The years of drug abuse tore up my immune system pretty good,’ he said at the time.”

Fans who believe depressed immune systems from cocaine abuse are relevant to torn abdominal muscles need a crash course on how to read the sports pages.

Irvin Muchnick’s CHRIS & NANCY: The True Story of the Benoit Murder-Suicide and Pro Wrestling’s Cocktail of Death will be published in the fall. See the book’s website,, and follow Irv at

Great Moments in Email, Part 2

An anonymous correspondent sent me a string  of messages, each one more intelligent than the last:

* “knowe who the diva was who was fooling around with benoit. it was your piece of shit mother.”

* “fuck you and benoit”

* “YOU HATE MCMAHON BECAUSE HE IS RICH AND ALSO FOR THE FACT THAT HE PUT YOUR STUPID UNCLE OUT OF BUSINESS.” (Uh … Sam Muchnick’s last show, before retiring at age 76, was on January 1, 1982, months before Vincent K. McMahon took over WWF from Vincent J. McMahon and his partners.)


Well, I’m definitely bald.

Irv Muchnick

Cruel Irony: Misawa’s Real Cause of Death Is ‘Better’ Storyline

According to Japanese news reports, Mitsuharu Misawa died of a spinal injury in the ring Saturday in Hiroshima, Japan. The initial report was that it was a heart attack.

Observers say that the back suplex that Misawa took before lying motionless was unremarkable, not a “botched spot.” It’s not known whether he suffered the fatal injury from that particular move or from an accumulation of suplexes for which he “sold” over many years, ranging from textbook-perfect “worked” “bumps,” in which his weight was properly distributed over the traumatized body part, to moves that were awkwardly executed or botched. Of the thousands of suplexes Misawa took, no matter how skilled he and his opponents were in the art of pro wrestling, some inevitably were botched.

Now here’s the cruelly ironic and painful truth about this industry: The explanation that Misawa died from punishment inside the ring is actually a better one, for business purposes, than the idea that he suffered a coronary. That makes the suplexes “real,” not “fake.” If Misawa’s company, Pro Wrestling NOAH, wished to push the envelope of bad taste, it could hang a “legend killer” tag on the wrestler who delivered his final back suplex. (When Chris Benoit inadvertently broke Sabu’s neck in a match, the incident was subtly exploited for Benoit’s credibility as a “crippler.”)

It makes one wonder why NOAH even helped circulate the incorrect and even less convenient story about Misawa’s heart. Perhaps no one actively fomented that rumor, which took on a life of its own. Perhaps people understandably weren’t thinking clearly in the ringside chaos of this horrible incident. Or perhaps wrestling people just reflexively tell even inconvenient untruths, because they can’t stop themselves.

Irv Muchnick

‘Steroid Cloud Hovers Over Baseball’s Feel-Good Stories’ … today in Beyond Chron

“Anyone who cares about good government must scour the Washington coverage critically. Similarly, if the public-health implications of sports’ steroid scandals matter, you need to read the sports pages with equal skepticism. The feel-good comeback narratives of two baseball players – Rick Ankiel of the St. Louis Cardinals and Josh Hamilton of the Texas Rangers – illustrate the latter point.”

Irv Muchnick

Irv’s Tweets

June 2009